How can a ballerina practice without her favorite ballet slippers? Madelyn Honey expressed her frustration in a phone call to best friend Scarlett Alexis, adding that she suspected they'd been stolen by a creepy fan. Madelyn's predicament became more dramatic when a hooded figure suddenly appeared, tied her wrists behind her back and tightened white rope around her black dance outfit. After she sat bound on a dark countertop above the floor, the intruder admitted that he had indeed taken her slippers because he was her greatest admirer; when Madelyn responded indignantly, he tape-gagged her. The weird fan enjoyed her struggling for a few moments but left to welcome Scarlett once he heard her arrive. When he returned, the bound and gagged ballerina's bare feet received his zealous attention as he promised Madelyn that she and her friend would soon enjoy some special time together.

Scarlett was surprised that Madelyn hadn't met her at the door, so she went searching for her friend but it was the disguised stranger whom she encountered after entering a bedroom. She struggled more vigorously than Madelyn but was also trapped in rope, then sat squirming on small bench with a scarf tied between her lips. The disturbed fan moved back and forth between the pair of trussed-up friends, returning to replace Scarlett's scarf-gag with white tape and later removing the ankle boots from her bare feet. Curled up on the bench, the dark-haired girl's eyes widened as his hands stroked her soles, although his promise to unite her with Madelyn brought some relief to Scarlett.